Consultation with Kentucky Heritage Council staff determined that the Amos Shinkle Summer Residence which was listed on the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) in 1983 continues to be eligible for listing under Criterion B and Criterion C. Under Criterion B, it is significant for its association with businessman, financier and civic leader Amos Shinkle and under Criterion C, it is significant as an outstanding example of a summer residence for a wealthy 19th century businessman.
Despite its change in use now serving as office space, the structure still reads as a residential property. Changes have occurred to the residence since its listing on the NRHP. A one-story smokehouse has been added to the north elevation as well as some changes to the brick on the east elevation of the ell and improvements to the foundation of the structure. The construction of the nearby I-275 in the early 70s has spurred much development in the area. The encroaching development of this area has the potential to endanger the future of this NRHP listed resource.