Consultation with Kentucky Heritage Council staff determined that the Eastminster Presbyterian Church is Eligible for listing on the National Register of Historic Places under Criterion C. Under Criterion C, the resource was found to be significant as an example of suburban ecclesiastical architecture designed by locally prominent architect, N. Warfield Gratz.
The church was designed for a capacity of 250 with Sunday School rooms in the basement and the classroom wing to be added later. The one-bay wings to either side, seen in the original rendering below, were not built exactly as designed but instead pushed back toward the rear of the sanctuary. The elevations on either side of the nave feature four stained glass windows with a round, stained glass window on the north elevation, where it likely illuminates the pulpit. That is very much in keeping with Presbyterianism with its emphasis on the pulpit of the church. A temporary church on the same parcel was utilized during construction of the new church building.